The Ribbon Cutting Economy

Watertown just spent $135,000. Why? To help us spend more money.
Our City Council approved a three-year contract with Retail Strategies, an Alabama firm hired to recruit new stores and restaurants.
More shopping. More jobs. More prosperity.
At least that's the sales pitch.
But economic research exposes an inconvenient truth: A new store can be great for that store’s business without being particularly good for the local economy.
We now have 135,000 reasons to understand the difference.
More Stores. Same Customers.
Here's a question rarely asked at ribbon cuttings: Where are the customers coming from?
Our town’s population has grown approximately 5% since 2020. Inflation-adjusted median household income has increased roughly 11% between recent five-year Census survey periods.
That's progress, but hardly a consumer spending explosion.
Meanwhile, businesses in town generated approximately $865 million in retail sales in 2022 (the latest figure I could fetch).
So, clearly, we know how to shop.
But here's the catch: Economic research shows that when population and purchasing power grow slowly, retail expansion can spread existing spending around rather than create new economic activity.
Imagine a national retailer opening in Watertown and generating $3 million in annual sales.
Wonderful!
Except $2 million might previously have gone to other Watertown businesses.
We've added a store, perhaps improved selection and competition, but haven't necessarily grown the local economy by $3 million.
Now imagine that retailer attracts shoppers from Milbank, Webster, or families who previously drove to Sioux Falls.
That's a different story.
The goal should be capturing dollars Watertown doesn't currently get, not paying someone to move dollars between cash registers.
Otherwise, we're celebrating economic musical chairs.
More Stores. More Jobs?
Surely a new retailer means new jobs? Not so fast.
An economic study examining Walmart openings found approximately 100 additional county retail jobs initially, but half that gain disappeared within five years as competing establishments contracted or closed.
Another study examined seven Cabela's openings and found no persistent employment increase in the affected counties or surrounding areas.
When a national chain hires 50 employees, those workers don't necessarily materialize out of thin air. Some may leave existing businesses. Others may fill positions that would have existed somewhere else.
And competing retailers respond by reducing staffing, cutting hours, or closing altogether.
New stores can still provide meaningful benefits: better wages, more choices, and stronger competition. But those deserve to be measured rather than assumed.
A job announcement tells us who's hiring. Economic development should tell us whether more people are working.
It's a distinction worth remembering when the oversized scissors come out.
Ribbons and Returns Aren’t the Same
The most troubling question isn't whether retail recruitment works. It's how we know.
Spending money on economic development doesn't automatically produce economic development. Retail Strategies will analyze our market, engage potential retailers, and help promote available properties.
All potentially useful.
But reports aren't results. Meetings aren't investments. And a new storefront doesn't establish that the consultant caused it to open.
A $135,000 contract might be an incredible bargain if it generates millions in additional economic activity. But it might also produce impressive presentations and very little additional prosperity.
The difference isn't something we should discover after the money is gone.
Watertown needs to measure the economic value created, not the economic activity advertised.
The Bottom Line
The goal of economic development shouldn’t be to increase the number of Chamber of Commerce photo ops. Instead, it should be to make Watertown and its citizens more prosperous.
Invitation to Connect: Did this column spark a thought, question, or critique? I want to hear it! Send your inquiry to thekobatcorner@gmail.com




