top of page

Watertown City Manager Responds During Closing Report to Open Forum Allegations Over Past Watertown Development Company Deal

1 minute ago
5 min read
Performance review form with Northeast Radio SD and Watertown logos, pen and glasses, plus a smiling man’s portrait inset.

Northeast Radio SD News – Watertown, SD - During his closing report near the end of Monday evening’s Watertown City Council meeting, City Manager Alan Stager responded on the record to allegations made earlier in the evening during the open forum by local manufacturer and former political candidate Neal Tapio regarding a past Watertown Development Company (WDC) property transaction.


Tapio Addresses Council During Open Forum

At the start of the Nov. 16 meeting during the five-minute public comment period, Tapio spoke to the council about his manufacturing company, Cuda Cleaning Systems, which he and his brother purchased at the start of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020 and relocated from Camas, Washington, to Watertown. Tapio noted that the Watertown Area Chamber of Commerce named him the 2021 Watertown Businessman of the Year for creating roughly 50 jobs and generating an estimated $10 million annual economic impact, before criticizing local government, legal, and business leaders over the handling of his company’s facility financing.


According to Tapio, when he and his brother signed a purchase agreement for a former Terex building and property in 2020, Stager—who was then the Terex signatory on the contract—recommended financing the property through a Watertown Development Company program. Tapio said the program promised no money down, 3% to 4% interest rates, and principal reduction.


Tapio told the council that WDC Business Development Director Michelle Kakacek put the terms in writing—outlining four low-interest loans, a servicing fee, and a five-year payoff calculated at approximately $398,000—with the WDC executive director and WDC attorney copied on the email. Tapio said his company assigned the purchase agreement to the WDC, signed a lease-purchase option, and made 56 consecutive monthly payments totaling nearly $250,000.


When he notified the WDC six months prior to the five-year anniversary of his intent to exercise the purchase option, Tapio alleged the WDC initially presented a payoff figure of $518,000—more than the original purchase price—before months of delays eventually led to a closing price of $405,000. Tapio claimed that during the dispute, he met multiple times with WDC board members, Mayor Ried Holien, and Stager, and alleged that a WDC board member threatened him with a defamation lawsuit if he continued raising the issue. He also claimed that both Watertown title companies declined to issue title insurance because the WDC did not provide loan payoff information.


Tapio further told the council that two months after closing on the building, Store Capital—the property owner of neighboring Persona, represented by attorneys Lee Schoenbeck and Joe Erickson—sued his company for adverse possession of 26 parking spots, with a trial scheduled to begin this week. Tapio argued that satellite imagery shows the disputed area was a grassy field until 2017 and that the state of South Dakota owned the land until 2005, breaking the statutory 20-year threshold for adverse possession. He alleged there appeared to be a “handshake deal” between the WDC and Persona or Store Capital representatives.


Tapio concluded his open forum remarks by stating that over the next 18 months, he and his brother intend to refer their findings to the Codington County State’s Attorney, the South Dakota Attorney General, the U.S. Attorney, law enforcement, and the South Dakota Bar Association.

Promotional banner for Northeast Radio SD urging users to subscribe for local Watertown news, with bold red, black, and white text.

Stager Addresses Open Forum Claims and Anonymous Complaint in Manager’s Report

At the end of the meeting during the scheduled city manager’s report, Stager said he had not originally planned to speak on the matter, but felt it was important to place the facts from the public record before the council rather than letting specific accusations made at the podium go unanswered.


Stager noted that both he and Holien had sat down and listened to Tapio’s allegations for well over a year. Clarifying his own role at the time of the transactions, Stager stated for the record that he was not on the Watertown Development Company Board of Directors when Tapio purchased the building for $517,000, nor was he on the WDC board or involved in city government when Tapio completed the lease buyout for $402,000.

“I went through the entire history and allegations with him twice, and at the conclusion of each one of those, I said, ‘So you got the deal you wanted,’” Stager said. “And he admitted within about $4,000, or about 1% of the transaction, he got the deal he was anticipating.”

Stager added that Tapio left out substantial financial benefits his business received from taxpayers and the WDC during the arrangement.

“What he fails to mention is he’s recognized a rather substantial gain on the real property that was financed by taxpayers and the Watertown Development Company at below-market rates,” Stager said. “What he also fails to mention is he received a tax benefit on the property taxes worth at least $11,000 because the property utilized the exempt status of the WDC for two years of his holding of that property.”

Stager said he had refrained from bringing up those details during the recent political campaign because he believed doing so during an election was inappropriate.

“I am proud to have helped Neal Tapio come to this community during COVID,” Stager said. “I’m proud that we’ve helped him establish the business making and selling these washing machines. We should all be proud of that. But these baseless claims, the slanderous remarks, have no business at this podium.”

Anonymous Complaint Against Council Member Refuted

During the same report, Stager also addressed a separate anonymous complaint recently submitted to the city regarding an unnamed member of the City Council.

According to Stager, the anonymous complaint alleged that in exchange for campaign contributions and favorable business treatment at the council member’s private business, a local business and its principals were receiving special treatment from the City Council.


Stager said the city takes public complaints seriously, but noted the allegation is demonstrably false because neither the business nor its principals have had any business before the City Council, the Planning Commission, the Board of Adjustment, or any other segment of city government.

“We will address complaints, but they can’t be anonymous,” Stager said. “We have to be able to go back to someone and say, ‘Please provide some more detail on what this complaint is.’... It’s really impossible for any one of you to act individually to give special treatment to anyone, much less you as an entire body can’t give special treatment to the principals or a business that hasn’t had any business before you. So on the face of it, I see it as a baseless claim, but I did want to address it.”

2027 Street Projects and WMU Water Main Coordination

Prior to addressing the open forum remarks and the anonymous complaint, Stager opened his report with updates on upcoming 2027 infrastructure coordination:


·         North Broadway Street Project: The city’s engineering team met earlier in the week with neighborhood residents in the North Broadway area to plan 2027 street and utility work, aiming to improve planning compared to previous projects on Fifth Avenue.

·         WMU Water Main Replacements: Watertown Municipal Utilities (WMU) has an aggressive multi-year plan to replace water mains throughout the central part of the city. Because WMU’s schedule does not currently align with the city’s Capital Improvement Plan timeline for full street reconstruction, Stager said city staff and WMU need to identify alternative funding sources so the city can properly reconstruct streets rather than merely patching trenches over replaced water mains.

·         WMU Enterprise Budget Review: Stager invited the public to attend WMU’s upcoming budget review at the Municipal Utilities building to see the utility enterprise funds budget and its impact on rates.

bottom of page